Thursday, November 16, 2006

On writing versus blogging

I've had this blog for going on two and a half years now, and it's interesting to see how writing posts has influenced my "other" writing.

There is the obvious difference in interface. When I add citations to a paper, I almost wish I had a tool that could highlight text and add a clickable link to a reference (the emacs extension RefTeX is great, though: it makes adding citations, references and labels blindingly easy).

I structure sentences differently as well. Links in blogs are added en passant, without interrupting the text. Citations in papers have to be worked into the sentence structure carefully (that is, if you believe the maxim that a citation is not a noun). This causes no end of confusion when I write sentences in a paper; I often have to rephrase the sentence to conform to "normal" citation format. I will add though that the parenthetical style of mentioning citations makes sense with written documents, but with online hyperlinked PDF documents I would actually prefer blog-style linking. But then again, we still have paper proceedings, so there's a long way to go for that...

It's natural that a blog post is more chatty and personal, and a paper is more formal. But writing a blog has encouraged me to be less stuffy and more breezy in parts of a paper that merit it (introductions, discussion, etc). This can only be a good thing; as the famous war cry goes, 'Eschew obfuscation' !

Writing a blog also shakes out some of the ghastlier linguistic tics that infect my writing. It's actually shocking how many there are, and how easily they evade detection.

I wouldn't recommend writing a blog solely as a way of improving (or expanding) your writing skills. But it does have benefits beyond being a soapbox for one's bloviations.



  1. I don't know about blogging, because I don't blog. But I do know that spending the day instant messaging with my friends and collegues has wrecked my writing.  

    Posted by Anonymous

  2. I have noticed the same thing. I wrote the bulk of my dissertation two years ago, then took a break during which I blogged every day. Now that I am finishing my Dissertation (again) I am appalled at some of my writing style of the past and now I write in a much more clear style. I also took my old published papers a couple of months ago and practically re-wrote them and reposted that on my blog. That was quite a revelatory excercise! 

    Posted by coturnix

  3. Actually for me blogging helped to improve the speed of structuring an idea into text. I am not a native speaker so there is more room for improvement :)


Disqus for The Geomblog